Forty years ago on Simchat Torah, Eliahu Abergil, the Sephardic rabbi of Jerusalem’s Baka neighbourhood, arrived at a service held by the fledgling Kol HaNeshama...
Forty years ago on Simchat Torah, Eliahu Abergil, the Sephardic rabbi of Jerusalem’s Baka neighbourhood, arrived at a service held by the fledgling Kol HaNeshama Reform congregation with a group of followers after learning that women were dancing with Torah scrolls alongside men, and the confrontation turned physical, with some of his followers trying to wrest the scrolls from worshippers before police intervened. New York-born Levi Weiman-Kelman, ordained at the Conservative Jewish Theological Seminary, had founded Kol HaNeshama in 1984 in his living room, with many early members young English-speaking immigrants. Four decades later the congregation again faced hostility, with five incidents over a few weeks including break-ins, vandalism and harassment, and its leaders say intolerance has hardened in Israeli society and accuse political leaders of helping create the climate, whether through inflammatory rhetoric or by failing to condemn the attacks. At a solidarity gathering in the synagogue’s sukkah after the latest attacks, Weiman-Kelman, a former president of Rabbis for Human Rights, pointed to a countervailing change: the circle of people willing to stand with Kol HaNeshama has grown considerably, and while in 1986 the communities that rallied were overwhelmingly Reform, this time Orthodox rabbis and congregations were among those who signed letters of support and came to stand alongside a community whose theology and practices they do not necessarily share. Oded Mazor, the current rabbi, said some Orthodox communities were explicit that they are not Reform and do not think alike but value the congregation and will defend its right to be who it is, and that responsibility for a shared, pluralistic and tolerant public space belongs to everyone together. The Anti-Defamation League chief executive Jonathan Greenblatt attended the first Friday services after Sukkot, writing on X that no Jew should feel unsafe because of the way they practise Judaism. Police arrested three minors suspected of involvement in incidents that included eggs thrown at worshippers on Rosh Hashanah and objects hurled through a window before Yom Kippur, but nearly two months later Mazor said the congregation had received no further update and police had not responded to several inquiries from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. The youths appeared religious but not haredi, and congregants also reported harassment and homophobic comments. Mazor believes the attacks were aimed not only at the congregation’s Reform identity but at its embrace of LGBTQ inclusion, since the perpetrators did not vandalise prayer books or graffiti the walls but came to tear down a Pride flag. The crowd in the sukkah, some 200 strong at its peak, reflected a cross-section of Jerusalem Jewish life and included David Goodman and Amirit Rosen, co-rabbis of Moreshet Avraham, a congregation affiliated with the Masorti movement; Goodman said an attack on a Jew because of their Jewish identity is an attack on him, all the more so when it happens to neighbours in Jerusalem. The gathering was organised with the support of Reshut Harabim, an umbrella network of more than 65 Jewish organisations and congregations promoting pluralistic Jewish life in Jerusalem, and as part of a nationwide sukkah initiative bringing Israelis from different religious and political backgrounds together, and Goodman said such networks explain why the response differs from the 1980s, since disparate communities have become a network that knows how to stand together. Several Jerusalem organisations later chose Kol HaNeshama to host a memorial marking the anniversary of the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. The congregation has about 280 member families and serves a much larger circle including native Israelis and immigrants raised Reform, Conservative, Orthodox or with no affiliation. After the 1986 confrontation, Mayor Teddy Kollek helped it secure a permanent home in Baka, leasing an abandoned stone building it renovated and later expanded. It has deep roots in the English-speaking immigrant community, counting among its worshippers the New York Times senior correspondent Isabel Kershner, the former ambassador to Germany Jeremy Issacharoff and the solar-energy entrepreneur Yossi Abramowitz, but never became a simple expatriate transplant: services are participatory, retain more of the traditional prayer sequence than classical Reform Judaism, and incorporate meditation, chanting and elements that might once have been considered New Age, along with gender-diverse language for God that later spread to other congregations. The longtime congregant Laura Zeitlin, who grew up in Argentina without a particular denomination, said the synagogue became a family home where she could sit beside her husband and participate fully, and her frustration over the attacks was directed at a lack of mutual respect rather than at religious difference. Ezra Ende, rabbi of the Reform congregation HaDror, said other Jerusalem congregations have also faced threats and that there is more violence in Israel today, which all liberal communities feel. Mayor Moshe Lion’s response was a recurring complaint: he spoke privately with Mazor before Yom Kippur and expressed support but did not publicly name the synagogue when condemning the attacks, despite calls from the Union for Reform Judaism president Rick Jacobs and the Knesset member Gilad Kariv, and Ende said that says everything. Lion later issued a general statement condemning attacks on others’ religious practices, customs and ways of life, and his office rejected suggestions that political considerations including sensitivity to the large haredi electorate explained his reluctance, telling the agency that the city had chosen not to draw further attention so as not to escalate; he declined an invitation to the sukkah gathering, citing prior commitments. Naama Kelman, Weiman-Kelman’s sister and a former dean of Hebrew Union College’s Jerusalem campus, where she became the first woman ordained a rabbi in Israel in 1992, noted that Lion had addressed students there about a year earlier but may have been more comfortable because it also serves as an event venue and is not publicly identified primarily as Reform. She said the attacks are a direct result of the incitement of National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and hateful, messianic extremist Judaism, and that she was terrified by officials mocking Reform Judaism, citing the minister May Golan telling Kariv in the Knesset that he marries dogs in his bizarre synagogues and the Likud lawmaker Galit Distel Atbaryan saying she would come and celebrate a bar mitzvah for a dog before ordering him removed from a committee; the same rhetoric surfaced during one Yom Kippur incident, when two youths harassing worshippers arrived with a large dog and asked to arrange a bar mitzvah for it. Mazor called the 27 October parliamentary elections, which produced no clear governing majority, critical for Israel’s future as both a Jewish and democratic state, and said the synagogue hosts dozens of school and pre-army academy groups each year, many with little knowledge of Reform Judaism, because such encounters make conversation possible where otherwise students would know only what extremists tell them.